Josh Hadro

Looking at NYC 311 Complaint Data

[This post was assembled from a Twitter thread in October 2021.]


I was curious about the claims made here re: NYPD closing out complaints in less than 5 minutes [Note: the original tweet I was quoting seems to be gone, but that quote tweet was itself referencing this tweet from then NYC Council Speaker Corey Johnson, accusing NYPD of falsifying responses to parking complaints], and since NYC makes @NYC311 data openly available, I thought I would take a look. The number of 311 complaints closed in less than 5 minutes has increased a lot since the pandemic!

Map of NYC 311 parking complaints closed in under 5 minutes, showing unusual clustering patterns by community board

But it's more than just closing tickets in < 5min -- if you look by community board, you see a lot of clustering of resolution descriptions that sure looks a bit funny. For example, CB6 in Brooklyn has seen a lot of "not our jurisdiction" closures ramp up in the last few months.

Table showing 311 complaint resolution descriptions for Brooklyn Community Board 6, with suspicious clustering of identical closure reasons

Here are the other 3 boroughs, which all exhibit this to some degree when you look at complaints closed out in under 5 minutes. [Ed note: When I published this to Twitter, I definitely had Staten Island in there, but the Twitter archive didn't seem to capture that last tweet]

NYC 311 complaint data showing fast-closed complaints in Manhattan community boards

NYC 311 complaint data showing fast-closed complaints in Queens community boards

NYC 311 complaint data showing fast-closed complaints in the Bronx and Staten Island